The New York City Race Riot (1900)

November 22, 2017 
/ Contributed By: Will Mack

Scene from the New York City Race Riot of 1900

Public Domain Image

The 1900 New York City, New York Race Riot began following an incident between Arthur J. Harris, a black man, and a white undercover police officer, Robert J. Thorpe, outside the apartment of Harris and his girlfriend May Enoch in the Tenderloin section of New York City.  At 2:00 a.m. on August 13, Harris witnessed Thorpe grabbing Enoch, whom Thorpe believed to be a prostitute soliciting customers.  Harris, not knowing that Thorpe was a police officer, attacked Thorpe and cut him with a knife.  Both Harris and Enoch fled the scene.  Harris left for his mother’s home in Washington D.C.and Enoch ran into her apartment where she was later arrested.   Thorpe, who was also the son in-law of Acting Captain John Cooney of the local Twentieth Police Precinct, was taken to Roosevelt Hospital where he died the next day.

The Tenderloin was a traditionally Irish section of New York that was becoming increasingly integrated by Southern black migrants looking for work in New York. Thorpe’s death pushed racial tensions between the two groups in the neighborhood to the edge.

On August 15, the day before Thorpe’s funeral, a fight broke out near Thorpe’s family’s home between a white man, Thomas J. Healy, and a black man, Spencer Walters.  Walters was beaten to near death by a white mob that gathered.  This assault touched off the riot.

The word spread that blacks would be assaulted and they were soon attacked by white street gangs throughout the Tenderloin and surrounding areas.  Black people were randomly assaulted as they returned home from work prompting many to stay at their place of employment rather than return to their residences.

New York City Mayor Robert Van Wyck and Police Chief William Devery sent 700 police into the Tenderloin to quell the rebellion.  Black men and women, however, were disproportionately arrested during the riot and many were severely beaten while in police custody.

On August 16, the riot subsided.  The next day, black people began arming themselves and a black defense committee, the Citizens Protective League (CPL), was formed on September 3.  Approximately 35 people were arrested and 60 people injured during the riot, mostly black people.  There were no reported deaths.

For more than a month after the riot, daily incidents of racial violence continued and police reported that blacks threw bricks, bottles, and garbage at them from the rooftops.  No legal action was ever taken against the police involved in the riot despite pleas from the CPL and wide spread accusations of police brutality against black people in the New York City press.  Harris was arrested and convicted in the death of Thorpe and was sentenced to life in prison. He died there on December 20, 1908.

Author Profile

Will Mack is a graduate student at Southern New Hampshire University and will receive his MA in United States history in the spring of 2018. Will plans on advancing to a doctoral program in the fall of 2019 to focus on African American history, the civil rights movement, radicalism, the development of the carceral state, and labor history in the US. Will received his BA in history from Rutgers University-New Brunswick, New Jersey in 1999 and grew up in New York City.

CITE THIS ENTRY IN APA FORMAT:

Mack, W. (2017, November 22). The New York City Race Riot (1900). BlackPast.org. https://new.blackpast.org/african-american-history/1900-new-york-city-race-riot-1900/

Source of the Author's Information:

Gilbert Osofsky, “Race Riot, 1900: A Study of Ethnic Violence,” The Journal of Negro Education, 32, no. 1 (Winter, 1963), http://www.jstor.org/stable/2294487; Marilyn Johnson, Street Justice: A History of Police Violence in New York City, (Boston: Beacon Press, 2003).

Further Reading